Recent California Election: a Cash Cow Tipping Contest
About ten years ago, I had an epiphany. I noticed that real jobs
kept disappearing and government jobs just kept on growing. What
I realized was... groups of motivated voters win elections and
money is the best motivator of all. So I thought, "When
government gets big enough, won't government workers turn out in
droves to protect their turf, and start voting, unchecked, for
bigger, better government?"
I think that day may have arrived. The most motivated voters in
California are definitely those who stand to make or protect a
buck. As the size of government grew, government workers,
contractors, and their family members turn out and regularly
vote in favor of themselves, and why not?
The recent California election was decided by a strong turn-out
by unions who were mad at the governor for trying to institute a
few toothless reforms. The reforms seemed so mild that the
average voter couldn't see how they would help. Since most
voters were not excited, they didn't show up at the polls.
The cheerleader for the defeat of the reform initiatives was
California Teachers Assn. President Barbara Kerr who joined with
other unions to pump $100-million into defeating
Schwarzenegger's initiatives. She easily out-wasted the governor
who she says "wasted $50 million" in calling the election.
She also said "he does not have the courage to apologize".
Apologize for what? He was elected as a reformer, we just didn't
realize how hard it would be, or should I say, how bad he would
be at doing it. As a parent, I wish she would apologize for
taking $50 million dollars out of the teacher's pockets and
spending it on thousands of marathon ads that nobody watched.
The direct spending on the election and election advertising was
well in excess of $300 million dollars. The cost disturbs me but
what I really can't get over is the evidence it gives me that
the citizens of Californian have lost the ability to govern. We
never talk about or vote on big changes, but we spend enormous
amounts of energy fighting over small, incremental improvements
in provision serving special interest.
In addition to this election, here are some additional examples.
When the 2000 energy crisis showed the real incompetence of the
legislature, nobody was fired. The blame was shifted to the Fed.
When the budget crisis rose in 2003, Californians fired their
governor. They were especially incensed as he continued to honor
his reelection commitments to special interests while the state
was in crisis. But, he was not the only offender, and the
electorate did not fire a single incumbent member in the State
Legislature; not one, go figure?
Californians also rejected a proposition to change the way
political boundaries are drawn. The legislature raised several
million to crush this move. They like it the way it is now -
nice and predictable. The legislature has drawn district lines
in a way that completely eliminates contestable elections. If
you get nominated by the controlling party, you always get
elected. If you are an incumbent, you always get re-elected.
We have a constitution that demands a balanced budget, yet there
hasn't been one in years and none are on the horizon. We put no
energy into fixing a broken budgeting process, yet we spend
billions on legitimizing bookkeeping tricks to keep the state
afloat for another year.
Californian's replaced their governor with Schwarzenegger, when
they got angry,. But in this recent election, the unions were
easily able to defeat his mild reforms. Why? Because there is
more of them than we realized, and perhaps he didn't tackle the
states problem's in any meaningful way. It seems like he got
advice from his own special interests, and he got bad advice.
He asked voters to change rules for the political use of public
employee union dues, and teacher tenure - as if any of these
really would solve the state's problems.
I am a member of a very small minority. I don't belong to any of
the powerful special interest groups currently buying favorable
state laws. Will I ever again see a piece of legislation that
serves the general good of the state?
Aw come on, teachers, police, firefighters, gun-owner, casinos,
etc.; how about throwing us a bone before you tip the cow over.
How about doing a little something to fix our schools. Or
perhaps we could improve a few roads, patch up the health care
system, or make a dent in our border issues.
About the author:
John Thomas is an author, mentor, and business consultant who
works exclusively with entrepreneurs and owners of small and
mid-size businesses. He provides advice on web site promotion at
TrafficistheKey.com.